Use a small set of preferences and a limited shortlist, then make a decision within a reasonable time. More options can be enjoyable to browse, but they do not need to turn every evening into a lengthy comparison exercise.
Choose the kind of evening
Decide on mood, length and whether you want something familiar or new. Those three choices can eliminate many unsuitable options without detailed research. If several people are watching, agree on the shared boundaries before everyone starts proposing unrelated titles.
Limit the selection round
Each person can offer one or two choices, with a simple way to decide. Keep a separate list for titles that sound interesting but do not fit tonight. This acknowledges good suggestions without allowing the immediate choice to expand endlessly.
Accept a good fit
The aim is an enjoyable session, not proof that no better film exists anywhere. Once the group chooses a suitable title, start watching. If it clearly fails to suit the audience, change deliberately rather than opening and abandoning a dozen items without giving any a chance.
